Why Socrates Died

"Clarity, confident arguing, good sense … The cleverness of Waterfield’s richly told and enjoyable book is that he uses the death of Socrates as a way of introducing a wonderfully full picture of Athens in the fifth century … As clear an exegesis of the Peloponnesian War as the general reader will find … Waterfield builds up a cogent picture"

- Charlotte Higgins, Guardian

"Waterfield is an accomplished guide … we get a vivid account of the vested interests of the day … absolutely secure in his material, Waterfield can stride off on thematic digressions such as the nature and point of law … [he] is sympathetic and skilful. His physical delight in Greece resonates. He is sharp with words, robust in his knowledge of antiquity, and honest. Socrates – who encouraged men to reason and question, “to dispel – would have approved”"

- - Bettany Hughes, The Times

"Robin Waterfield’s erudite but deeply engaging book takes a historian’s scalpel to the myths. Richly detailed, briskly written, it fills in the bloodstained background of Athens around 400 BC: the enervating wars with Sparta, the brutal regime of the “Thirty Tyrants”, the fatal political charisma of Socrates’ ex-lover and pupil, Alcibiades. Even if your vote would still have let the sceptic dodge the poison, you grasp the purpose of the prosecution case. History defeats hindsight"

- Boyd Tonkin, Independent

"Incisive and readable … Waterfield certainly managed to keep my interest, and even provide me with some new insights, and he will certainly do the same for the majority of readers … Waterfield paints for us in a manner both learned and lively"

- John Dillon, Irish Times

"Lucid, careful and balanced … an admirably detailed and nuanced account of the context of the trial and the range of factors in play in its outcome"

- Michael Trapp, Anglo-Hellenic Review

"Waterfield … offers an informed and well-written account of classical Athenian history … readable and interesting … he describes well the ambitious and unscrupulous characters that dominated the public life of the age"

- Barbara Graziosi, Times Higher Education Supplement

"Engaging, informative and beautifully written … It presents a serious and thought-provoking challenge to anyone who believes that we can understand why Socrates was tried and executed merely by reading the apologies of Plato and Xenophon"

- Thomas C. Brickhouse, Polis

"Waterfield’s narrative brings 399 BCE to life, giving us a genuine sense of how it felt to live through the social unrest and panic that swept Socrates into the abyss … essential reading for everyone interested in Socrates and his time … Why Socrates Died presents a theory about Socrates’ trial that many people will find appealing because of its sensitivity to the trial’s place and time. And it does this while resolving some of the most serious problems with similar views … Waterfield has updated the case for a political motive behind Socrates’ trial, and he has given us some very good reasons to consider it. His book points us in a new direction, and it is a promising one: we should focus primarily on reconstructing the political culture of Socrates’ trial, not Socrates’ irrecoverable beliefs, which, after all, probably were not known or understood by anyone on his jury, and may not have been reported by Xenophon or Plato. It is now up to others to find out whether this new path will bear fruit. Let the next round of debates begin!"

- Mark Ralkowski, Ancient Philosophy

"Admirably clear and informative … shows enviable mastery of the ancient sources"

- C.C.W. Taylor, Phronesis

"Thorough and fair-minded"

- Peter Jones, Literary Review

"Enormously useful"

- William M. Calder III, Classical Journal

"A lively revision of the evidence"

- Frederic Raphael, truthdig

"Remarkable and thoroughly original"

- Kevin Hartnett, Christian Science Monitor